Will Your Smoke Alarms Save You?

There Are Two Residential Smoke Alarm Technologies

Ionization

Dangerously Defective

Photoelectric

Highly Effective

In Most Homes

Contain Radioactive Material

Excessive False Alarms

In Most Commercial Buildings

No Radioactive Material

Few False Alarms

22 Jan 2018 ~ ongoing. . .

ABC Special Investigation

Fire & Rescue New South Wales (FRNSW)
Smoke Alarm Research
"Flawed & Dangerous"

Safety advocates warn lives at risk after Fire & Rescue NSW reverses
stand on ionization alarms taken by former Commissioner Greg Mullins

"Greg Mullins, FRNSW's
  previous Commissioner,

  took a brave, no compromise
  stand.
  He warned that the
 
Australian smoke alarm
  standard is flawed and that
  ionization smoke alarms

  should be banned."
  Adrian Butler & Karl Westwell,

  Co-Founders, WFSF
  QLD, Australia | 8 Sept 2018

"...he had working alarms...

but they simply didn't work."

M O R E > > >

 

Erin Yarwood (Matt's Fiancée), Aluna & Celebrity Chef, Matt Golinski

9 July 2018

Why this Common Safety Device Could be Banned from Homes

Safety experts calling for the ionization smoke alarms in most QLD homes to be banned.

M O R E  > > >

9 July 2018

The CSIRO has been Taken to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal

Pressure mounts on the CSIRO to release sensitive ionization smoke alarm test data.

M O R E  > > >

2 July 2018

Fire Safety Experts Call for Banning of Common Smoke Alarm

Ionization detectors are putting lives at risk . . . replace them immediately.

M O R E  > > >

The Aquarium Test
Why Your Smoke Alarm May Not Save You

Why Ionization Alarms Activate when Cooking but Often Remain Silent in Deadly Fires

Bob Segall

Award-Winning, Senior Investigative Reporter

Roger Johnson, Former Indiana State Fire Marshal

"The most important life-
safety issue the fire service will face in our lifetime."

Part 4 of 12 - Eyewitness News 'Deadly Delay' Investigation

WTHR Channel 13  |  Indiana, USA  |  July 2007 - 6 Minutes

"A Fallacy. An Absolute Myth. . ."

"People have said that one is good for flaming fires (ionization) and one is

 good for smoldering (photoelectric). In my experience as a firefighter just

 about every fire I have ever been to started as a smoldering fire and went

 through a stage until it became a flaming fire. To say that they are equal
 and good for different circumstances is to me a fallacy. An absolute myth."

Commissioner Greg Mullin's testimony before Australian Senate Smoke Alarm Inquiry
Canberra, ACT, Australia | 4 Dec 2015 | Hansard Report - page 3, paragraph 12

Commissioner Greg Mullins
Former Commissioner FRNSW

Former President AFAC

An Important Message from the
World Fire Safety Foundation

Adrian Butler

"Australia's Ralph Nader"

Former Full Time Firefighter

Chairman, Co-Founder

12 December 2018

 

Ionization Smoke Alarms
Should Be Banned

 

Greetings from Australia

 

Australian Government (CSIRO) scientific test data proves ionization smoke alarms may not save you from most deadly fires. Australia's smoke alarm standard is flawed and lives will be lost until it is brought into line with the new U.S. standard (due 2020).

 

Examine the ABC's ongoing 'Special Investigation'.

60 Minutes' exposé, 'The Alarming Truth', the stand taken by Consumer New Zealand and NSW former Fire Commissioner are all below.

 

Discover the truth. Replace all ionization alarms in your home with photoelectric alarms to properly protect your family. However, if you're a tenant, visit our Tenant's Lives Matter website.

 

We don't solicit or accept donations . . . so please, help us spread this message.

 

Thank You.

 

Sincerely,

 

Adrian Butler & Karl Westwell

Co-Founders

World Fire Safety Foundation

Karl Westwell

Director of Research

Co-Founder

World Fire Safety Foundation

15 Kurara Court, Narangba, Queensland, Australia 4504

Founded March 2000  |  Self (privately) funded  |  Does not sell anything  |  Does not solicit or accept donations

Lives Have Been Lost Because the Public Has Not Been Told the Truth

"I've often been cautioned that I should be quiet "because we do not..
  want the public to lose faith in smoke detectors." This statement..

 implies lives will be lost if we tell the American public the truth..

 

 I think the exact opposite is true. How many lives have been..
lost because the American public was not told the truth?”

Extract : Deputy Chief Fleming's letter to the U.S. Fire Administration (USFA)

From the WFSF's 'C.A.N. Report' | Feb 2007 | Page 6

Chief Jay Fleming
Boston Fire Dept, MA, USA
Smoke Alarm World Expert

"It's About Banning the Ionization Technology"

"It's about banning the ionization technology
and only having the photoelectric technology."

Quote from Chief Marc McGinn,  Albany Fire Dept, CA, USA
Channel 7 News, Today Tonight | Sydney, Australia | 03 May 2011

Chief Marc McGinn (Ret)
Albany Fire Dept, CA, USA

on Australian National TV

Chief Marc McGinn (Ret)
Albany Fire Dept, CA, USA
Extract: '
California Makes A Stand'

Former Fire Commissioner* Wants
Ionization Smoke Alarms Banned

Channel 7 News  |   NSW Edition  |   Feb 2016 - 106 seconds

0:00  “The Fire Commissioner* says Australia’s most common
          (ionization) smoke alarm should be banned.”

*After 39 years of service, FRNSW Commissioner and AFAC President Greg Mullins retired in 2017.

Upgrade on Smoke Detectors

Channel 10 News  |  Dec 2015   |   107 seconds

0:33 “The research that Commissioner Mullins has spoken about
         quite definitively says that a photoelectric smoke alarm is better."

Quote by David Isaac, Fire Protection Engineer, | Standard Australia FP002 Committee Member | Dec 2015

Adam Dalrymple, Director Fire Safety, Metropolitan Fire Brigade, Melbourne, Australia | Smoke Alarm Senate Hearing | Dec 2015

0:54 “Photoelectric detectors sense smoldering fires on average
         30 minutes
* earlier than ionization detectors.”

*WARNING
After Commissioner Mullins retired in Jan 2017, a false claim aired on national Australian TV
on 22 Jan 2018. The claim was based on flawed FRNSW research where it was stated that
ionization smoke alarms respond to smoldering fires just "
30 seconds to a minute" slower
than photoelectrics. This is false. Ionization smoke alarms are on average
30 Minutes Slower
to activate in the early, smoldering stage of fire.

Fire & Rescue NSW "Flawed & Dangerous" Research

M O R E > > >

AUSTRALIAN SENATE SMOKE ALARM INQUIRY

Testimony & Submissions

Second Hearing - Parliament House, Canberra, ACT  |  4 December 2015

Rebecca Le Tourneau - Producer, 60 Minutes Australia

"Industry Politics which are wasting time and risking more lives . . . Ensure the Australian
 Building Codes Board takes it head out of the sand and mandates interconnected
 photoelectric smoke alarms
across Australia before the next family fire takes its next family."

Rebecca Le Tourneau, 60 Minutes Producer of the ionization smoke alarm exposé, 'The Alarming Truth' (see film below)

Rebecca Le Tourneau

Producer, 60 Minutes

60 Minutes' Submission > > >

David Isaac's Testimony > > >

". . .no manufacturer wants  to admit, there is any..
performance problem with ionization smoke alarms."

David Isaac, Fire & Safety Technologies Pty Ltd  |  Australia's leading
fire safety expert  |  Standards Australia Committee FP002  member

David Isaac - Fire & Safety Technologies Pty Ltd

David Isaac, Standards Australia Committee

Greg Mullins - FRNSW Commissioner *   |  AFAC President

". . . ionization alarms should be banned . . .  and the standard itself
    (AS3786-1993) is flawed."

*After 39 years of service, Australasia's most senior fire official, FRNSW Commissioner and
  Australasian Fire & Emergency Service Authorities Council President Greg Mullins, retired in 2017
  Note: AFAC is the peak representative body for all Australian & New Zealand fire brigades

Commissioner Mullin's Testimony > > >

Commissioner Mullins, President AFAC

May - June 2018

"Consumer N.Z. calling
 for ionization alarms to

 be pulled from shelves."

More > > >

"We think ionization

  alarms should not

 be sold in New Zealand."

More > > >

Major New Zealand Retailers Stop Selling Ionization Smoke Alarms.

More > > >

15 March 2017

M O R E > > >

Are Your Smoke Alarms Safe?

Former Firefighter Calls for Ban on Ionization Alarms

Adrian Butler
Chairman, WFSF

Sep 15 ~ Jan 2017

Queensland's Photoelectric-Only

Smoke Alarm Legislation

". . .  ionization . . .  we want these banned . . ."

M O R E > > >

Louie Naumovski
Founder, Logan House

Fire Support Network

20 May 2015

M O R E > > >

Dr Larry Marshall
CEO, CSIRO

'CSIRO ActivFire® Certification

is Costing Lives'

 

World Fire Safety Foundation

Open Letter to CSIRO CEO

 

"The world is a dangerous

  place to live; not because

  of the people who are evil,

  but because of the people

  who do nothing about it."

Albert Einstein

"Ignorance, allied with..
power, is the most.. ferocious enemy..
 justice can have."

James A Baldwin

"All that is required..
for evil to triumph .
is for good men..
 to do nothing."

Edmund Burke